CONE INDUSTRIES LTD ET AL v. HUTCHINSON INDUSTRIES CANADA INC
Summary of T-2117-07
The following information was obtained from the Federal Court or Federal Court of Appeal websites but is NOT the official version. See links below for the court websites.
Federal Court Type: Patent Impeachment
Parties and Lawyers:Party | Firm | Lawyer |
---|---|---|
CONE INDUSTRIES LTD | Prowse Chowne LLP | PROWSE, J CAMERON |
ERICKSON, TERRANCE D | ||
HOZACK, MURRAY G | ||
HUTCHINSON INDUSTRIES CANADA INC | ||
SCHELLENBERG, MELVIN B | ||
VELTIKOLD, JODY E |
Name | Number |
---|---|
DUMP VALVE FOR TANK | 2316589 |
Docket Summary (Google Translate to English)
(29) 2014-03-06 - EdmontonDiscontinuance on a without costs basis on behalf of Plaintiffs with consent on behalf of Defendant filed on 06-MAR-2014
Vancouver 14-JAN-2014 BEFORE Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Case Management Conference Result of Hearing: Case Management Discussions held with respect to the Settlement Agreement held by way of Conference Call Duration per day: 14-JAN-2014 from 08:55 to 09:00 Courtroom : Conference Room - Edmonton Court Registrar: Shelly Procyk Total Duration: 5min Appearances: Mr. Cameron Prowse (780) 429-7171 representing Plaintiff Mr. Eugene Gierczak (416) 595-8500 representing Defendant Comments: Counsel confirmed a settlement agreement is in place and the trial dates may be vacated. Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 895 page(s) 206 - 207 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
Successful facsimilie transmission report received from fax sent to counsel with respect to Directions, ID 76 placed on file on 07-JAN-2014
Memorandum to file from S. Procyk dated 07-JAN-2014 re: Notification to the Parties (Directions, ID 76). Today's date, I called counsel and spoke to the assistant of Mr. Prowse and left a voice mail message for Mr. Gierczak. Advised them of the Directions. Directions to be faxed to both. placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 07-JAN-2014 directing that "A case management conference shall be held with counsel for the parties on Tuesday, January 14, 2014 at 8:45 a.m. (Mountain)." placed on file on 07-JAN-2014 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Memorandum to file from B. Suter - Edmonton Registry, dated 05-DEC-2013 I spoke to Counsel for the Plaintiff today and he advised me verbally that the parties are very close to a settlement. He has sent his proposal to Cousel for the Defendant and he is just waiting for a reply. Copy of memo placed on file.
Memorandum to file from B. Suter dated 03-DEC-2013 At the request of the Case Management Judge, I called and left a message for Mr. J. Cameron Prowse requesting that the parties provide a letter to the Court re: the status of this proceeding, if there is any prospect of settlement and whether there would be any benefit in referring the matter to a dispute resolution conference? Copy of memo placed on file.
Letter from Counsel for the Plaintiffs to the Federal Court Registry in Edmonton dated 02-MAY-2013 "Further to the above matter, please be advised that counsel for Cone Industries and counsel for Hutchinson Industries Canada Inc. have agreed to exchange expert reports by July 26, 2013 and to exchange rebuttal reports by October 4, 2013. Since this is approximately six months before the scheduled trial, we trust you will find this acceptable. Should you have any questions or concerns please do not hesitate to contact me." Letter sent by fax to the Edmonton Registry received on 02-MAY-2013
Memorandum to file from B. Suter dated 03-APR-2013 Re: Notification to the parties. I contacted Mr. Prowse for the Plaintiffs and Mr. Gierczak for the Defendant to advise of the Directions of the Court dated April 3, 2013. Letter faxed to both parties, successful facsimile transmission report placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 03-APR-2013 directing that "The parties are directed to submit, either jointly or separately and by May 3, 2013, a proposed timetable for service of their expert reports and rebuttal reports." placed on file on 03-APR-2013 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Order (time and place) dated 26-NOV-2012 rendered by Chief Justice Crampton and signed by Judicial Administrator fixing Trial of the matter to be heard at Special Sitting in Edmonton on 14-APR-2014 to begin at 09:30 duration: 4d language: E Filed on 26-NOV-2012 cc's sent to parties entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1176 page(s) 41 - 41 Transmittal letters placed on file
Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 05-SEP-2012 re: Forwarding to the Trial Judicial Administrator to fix the Trial of the matter.
Minutes of Pre-Trial Conference filed on 27-AUG-2012
Order dated 27-AUG-2012 rendered by Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Pre-Trial Conference Result: bifurcation Order Filed on 27-AUG-2012 certified copies sent to parties Transmittal Letters placed on file. entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1167 page(s) 65 - 68 Interlocutory Decision
Draft Order concerning bifurcation received on 07-AUG-2012
Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 08-AUG-2012 re: draft minutes of PTC and draft bifurcation Order
Draft minutes of Pre-Trial Conference submitted by counsel for the Plaintiff placed on file on 07-AUG-2012
Edmonton 25-JUN-2012 BEFORE Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Pre-Trial Conference Result of Hearing: Matter adjourned to be fixed by the Chief Justice held in Court Duration per day: 25-JUN-2012 from 01:02 to 02:10 Courtroom : Examination for Discovery Room - Edmonton Court Registrar: Jennifer Sorvisto Total Duration: 1h 8min Appearances: Mr. J. Cameron Prowse (780) 439-7171 representing Plaintiffs Mr. Paul Barrette (780) 439-7171 representing Plaintiffs Mr. Eugene Gierczak (416) 595-8500 representing Defendant Comments: Counsel for the Plaintiffs to file draft minutes of PTC once approved by counsel for the Defendant Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 864 page(s) 362 - 364 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
Successful facsimilie transmission report received from fax sent to counsel with respect to Directions, ID 60. placed on file on 12-JUN-2012
Memorandum to file from S. Procyk dated 12-JUN-2012 re: Notification to the Parties (Directions ID 60). Today's date, I called counsel and spoke to Mr. Prowse and left a voice mail message for Mr. Gierczak advising of the Direction. Direction to be faxed to both. placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 12-JUN-2012 directing that "The pre-trial conference presently scheduled on June 28, 2012 shall proceed instead at the Federal Court in Edmonton on Monday, June 25, 2012 at 1:00 p.m." placed on file on 12-JUN-2012 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Successful facsimilie confirmation transmission report received from fax sent to counsel with respect to Directions ID 57 placed on file on 14-MAY-2012
Memorandum to file from S. Procyk dated 14-MAY-2012 re: Notification to the Parties. Today's date, I called counsel and left a voice mail message for Mr. Prowse and spoke to Mr. Gierczak. Advised of the Directions. To be faxed to both. placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 14-MAY-2012 directing that "The Pre-Trial conference shall be held in person with representatives of the parties and their solicitors at the Federal Court in Edmonton on June 28, 2012 at 11:30 a.m. (Mountain)." placed on file on 14-MAY-2012 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Letter from Plaintiffs dated 11-MAY-2012 providing dates of mutual availability for counsel for the PTC received on 11-MAY-2012
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 19-MAR-2012 directing that "The pre-trial conference scheduled on March 20, 2012 is adjourned to a date and time to be fixed by the Court." placed on file on 19-MAR-2012 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 19-MAR-2012 re: Defendant's letter dated 19-MAR-2012
Letter from Defendant dated 19-MAR-2012 seeking an adjournment of the PTC scheduled for 20-MAR-2012, with consent of the Plaintiffs received on 19-MAR-2012
Affidavit of service of Denise Boudreau sworn on 12-MAR-2012 on behalf of Defendant confirming service of Doc. 24 upon Plaintiffs by fax on 12-MAR-2012 filed on 13-MAR-2012
Supplementary Pre-trial conference memorandum on behalf of Defendant filed on 13-MAR-2012 in triplicate. 1 copy(ies) for the Court Sent directly to Presiding Judge.
Letter from Plaintiffs dated 13-MAR-2012 further to the Direction issued 19-DEC-2011, advising that the Plaintiff has no further materials to provide to the Court at this time. received on 13-MAR-2012
Successful facsimile transmittal of the Directions issued by the Court (Lafrenière, P.) on December 19, 2011 to both counsel for the Plaintiffs and the Defendants placed on file on 19-DEC-2011
Memorandum to file from G. Champagne, Edmonton Local Office dated 19-DEC-2011 Notification to the parties with respect to the Directions issued by the Court (Lafrenière, Prothonotary) on December 19, 2011: called counsel for the plaintiffs (Mr. Prowse) and the Directions will be sent via facsimile; called counsel for the Defendants and left a detailed voice mail stating the Directions would be sent via facsimile to the number on record. placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 19-DEC-2011 directing that "The pre-trial conference shall reconvene with counsel for the parties by teleconference on Tuesday, March 20, 2012 at 10:30 a.m. (MST). The parties shall serve and file a supplementary pre-trial conference memorandum, if any, no later than March 13, 2012." placed on file on 19-DEC-2011 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Covering letter from Plaintiffs dated 05-DEC-2011 concerning Requisition for continuation of Pre-Trial Conference placed on file on 05-DEC-2011
Requisition for pre-trial conference from Plaintiffs (continuation) received on 05-DEC-2011
Successful facsimile transmission confirmation received from fax sent to counsel with respect to Direction, ID 42 placed on file on 01-DEC-2011
Memorandum to file from S. Procyk, Edmonton dated 01-DEC-2011 re: Notification to the Parties (Direction ID 42). Today's date, I called counsel as follows: Left a voice mail message for Mr. Prowse advising of the Direction - to be faxed; spoke to Mr. Gierczak advised of the Direction - Direction to be faxed. placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 01-DEC-2011 directing that "On December 15, 2011, counsel for the Plaintiffs requested that the pre-trial conference be rescheduled. Despite repeated inquires from the Registry, the Plaintiffs have yet to provide the necessary information to action their request. At a minimum, the Court requires dates and times of availability of counsel of the parties, the proposed venue, and an estimated duration of the pre-trial conference. The Plaintiffs are directed to submit a proper requisition forthwith and no later than December 5, 2011." placed on file on 01-DEC-2011 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Letter from Plaintiffs dated 28-NOV-2011 providing update on the expert report and advising counsel will not be in a position to continue the PTC until early March, 2012. received on 01-DEC-2011
Letter from Plaintiffs dated 15-NOV-2011 advising that the settlement discussions have not resulted in the resolution of this matter. Accordingly, they are asking that the Pre-Trial Conference be rescheduled. received on 16-NOV-2011
Letter from the Plaintiffs dated 04-NOV-2011 "Further to the Court's request for a Status Report, I can advise that after the Pre-Trial Conference in September 2009 the parties had various settlement discussions unti about July 23, 2010..." received on 04-NOV-2011
Letter from Defendant dated 04-NOV-2011 "I confirm receipt of your letters dated October 5th, 2011 and October 31st, 2011 in connection with the above-noted matter...." received on 04-NOV-2011
Successful facsimile transmission of the Directions issued by the Court (Prothonotary Lafrenière) on October 31, 2011 to both counsel for the Plaintiffs and the Defendants placed on file on 31-OCT-2011
Memorandum to file from G. Champagne, Edmonton Local Office dated 31-OCT-2011 Notification to the parties with respect to the Directions issued by the Court on 31-OCT-2011: called both counsel - the Directions are to be sent via facsimile to the fax numbers on record as confirmed. placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 31-OCT-2011 directing that "The Plaintiffs are granted an extension of time to November 4, 2011 to provide a status report of the proceeding." placed on file on 31-OCT-2011 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Letter from Plaintiffs dated 28-OCT-2011 seeking to have a one week extension of time to provide a status update to the Court received on 28-OCT-2011
Successful facsimile transmission confirmation received from fax sent to Mr. Prowse and Mr. Gierczak with respect to Written Directions, ID 31 placed on file on 05-OCT-2011
Memorandum to file from S. Procyk, Edmonton dated 05-OCT-2011 re: Notification tot he Parties (Directions ID 31). Today's date, I called and spoke with counsel, Mr. Prowse and Mr. Gierczak. Advised them of the Directions. Directions to be faxed to both. placed on file.
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 05-OCT-2011 directing that "The Plaintiffs are directed to provide a status report of the proceeding no later than October 28, 2011." placed on file on 05-OCT-2011 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Edmonton 16-SEP-2009 BEFORE Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary Language: E Before the Court: Pre-Trial Conference Result of Hearing: Parties will have ongoing settlement discussions. Orders re: expert reports and bifircation and preparation of minutes of PTC will be suspended until the outcome of the discussions is known. PTC is adjourned sine die. held in Court Duration per day: 16-SEP-2009 from 10:21 to 12:26 Courtroom : Examination for Discovery Room - Edmonton Court Registrar: George Wenzel Total Duration: 2h5min Appearances: J. Cameron Prowse (780) 439-7171 representing Plaintiff Eugene Gierczak (416) 596-2132 representing Defendant Minutes of Hearing entered in Vol. 808 page(s) 468 - 471 Abstract of Hearing placed on file
Pre-trial conference memorandum on behalf of Defendant with proof of service upon Plaintiff on 14-SEP-2009 filed on 14-SEP-2009
Written directions received from the Court: Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary dated 14-SEP-2009 directing that "The Defendant's pre-trial conference memorandum shall be accepted for filing." placed on file on 15-SEP-2009 Confirmed in writing to the party(ies)
Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 14-SEP-2009 re: Request for directions re: filing of Defendant's PTC Memorandum (tendered beyond the time limit set by Rule 262)
Notice of pre-trial conference dated 27-JUL-2009 further to the directions of Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary fixing Pre-Trial Conference to be heard at Special Sitting in Edmonton on 16-SEP-2009 to begin at 10:00 duration: 3h language: E Filed on 27-JUL-2009 issued to parties
Covering letter from Plaintiffs dated 08-JUL-2009 concerning Doc. No. 20 placed on file on 08-JUL-2009
Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of J. Cameron Prowse confirming service of Doc. 20 upon Defendant by fax on 08-JUL-2009 filed on 08-JUL-2009
Pre-trial conference memorandum on behalf of Plaintiffs filed on 08-JUL-2009 in triplicate. 1 copy(ies) for the Court Sent directly to Presiding Judge.
Covering letter from Plaintiffs dated 06-JUL-2009 concerning Doc. Nos. 18 19 placed on file on 08-JUL-2009
Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of J. Cameron Prowse confirming service of Doc. 18 upon Defendant by fax on 06-JUL-2009 filed on 08-JUL-2009
Requisition for pre-trial conference from Plaintiffs filed on 08-JUL-2009 Tariff Any other action - $300.00
Order dated 19-JAN-2009 rendered by Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Letter from Plaintiff dated 14-JAN-2009 Result: "This Court Orders that: 1. The parties shall complete examinations for discovery, to be held in Edmonton and Toronto, by March 15, 2009. 2. The parties shall provide answers to undertakings arising from the first round of examiniations for discovery by April 30, 2009. 3. The parties shall complete examinations on answers to undertakings by June 15, 2009. 4. The Plaintiffs shall requisition a pre-trial conference in accordance with Rule 258 of the Federal Courts Rules by July 15, 2009." Filed on 20-JAN-2009 certified copies sent to parties Transmittal Letters placed on file. entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1044 page(s) 101 - 102 Interlocutory Decision
Letter from Plaintiffs dated 14-JAN-2009 providing the Agreed Proposed Timetable of Next Steps pursuant to Order dated 06-OCT-2008 received on 14-JAN-2009
Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of J. Cameron Prowse confirming service of affidavit of documents upon Defendant by telecopier on 27-NOV-2008 filed on 08-DEC-2008
Order dated 27-OCT-2008 rendered by Chief Justice Lutfy Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Order dated 07-OCT-2008 Result: "IT IS ORDERED pursuant to Rule 383 that Prothonotary Roger Lafrenière is assigned as Case Management Judge in this matter." Filed on 27-OCT-2008 certified copies sent to parties & to CAS-SATJ Offices: EDMONTON, TORONTO & VANCOUVER - Attn: Lafrenière, CMP Transmittal Letters placed on file. entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1037 page(s) 172 - 172 Interlocutory Decision
Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of J. Cameron Prowse confirming service of Defence to Counterclaim upon Defendant by fax on 24-OCT-2008 filed on 24-OCT-2008
Defence on behalf of Plaintiff to the Counterclaim filed on 24-OCT-2008
Affidavit of service of Katherine Salsman sworn on 14-OCT-2008 on behalf of Defendant confirming service of doc 11 upon Plaintiff by telecopier on 14-OCT-2008 with Exhibits A filed on 14-OCT-2008
Statement of Defence and Counterclaim pursuant to the Order of Roger R. Lafrenière, Esq. dated 6-OCT-2008 filed on 14-OCT-2008
Order dated 06-OCT-2008 rendered by Roger Lafrenière, Esq., Prothonotary Matter considered without personal appearance The Court's decision is with regard to Status Review Result: THIS COURT ORDERS that: 1. The action shall continue as a specially managed proceeding. 2. The Defendant is granted an extension of time to serve and file its Statement of Defence until October 14, 2008. 3. The Plaintiffs shall serve and file their Reply, if any, by October 24, 2008. 4. The parties shall exchange affidavits of documents within 30 days of the close of pleadings. 5. The Plaintiffs shall submit a joint schedule for completion of the next steps in the proceeding within 30 days of service of the parties' affidavit of documents. Filed on 07-OCT-2008 certified copies sent to parties Transmittal Letters placed on file. entered in J. & O. Book, volume 1035 page(s) 259 - 260 Interlocutory Decision
Communication to the Court from the Registry dated 06-OCT-2008 re: Rule 380 Submissions on behalf of the Plaintiffs
Solicitor's certificate of service on behalf of J. Cameron Prowse confirming service of doc. 8 upon Defendant by telecopier on 05-SEP-2008 filed on 05-SEP-2008
Submissions (Rule 380) on behalf of Plaintiffs to be dealt with in the Edmonton local office filed on 05-SEP-2008
Affidavit of service of Todne Bryan sworn on 27-AUG-2008 on behalf of Defendant confirming service of doc 6 upon the Plaintiffs by telecopier on 26-AUG-2008 with Exhibits A filed on 27-AUG-2008
Motion Record containing the following original document(s): 3 4 5 Number of copies received: 3 on behalf of Defendant filed on 27-AUG-2008
Written Representations contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Defendant concerning Motion in writing Doc. No. 3 filed on 27-AUG-2008
Consent on behalf of all parties to Motion Doc 3 contained within a Motion Record filed on 27-AUG-2008
Notice of Motion contained within a Motion Record on behalf of Defendant in writing to be dealt with in the Toronto local office for an extension of time to file the Defendant's Statement of Defence filed on 27-AUG-2008 Draft Order\\Judgment received.
Notice of Status Review by Guenette, R.P. to the parties and their solicitors requiring the Plaintiff to show cause by written submissions why this proceeding should not be dismissed for delay, within 15 days of the date of this notice. The defendant may serve & file representations within 7 days after being served with the representations of the plaintiffs The plaintiffs may serve & file a reply within 4 days after being served with the representations of the defendant. Filed on 21-AUG-2008 cc's sent to parties
Statement of Claim and 2 copies filed on 07-DEC-2007 Tariff other action - $150.00
The official version of the court proceeding information is available from the court websites directly: